Trick or Treat! Yes it’s that time again! Whether or not you participate in Halloween festivities, there is one thing that is hard to avoid this time of year: candy.
In October, if your little ones go trick or treating, attend church fall fests, or even just look cute while standing in line at the grocery store, someone is bound to give them candy! Some parents are more relaxed when it comes to junk food, and the sudden inpouring of chocolate, sticky candies, and jawbreakers doesn’t phase them. However there are others, like myself, who have a hard time allowing their children to undo the last month of healthy eating by binging for the next 3 months on candy full of sugar, artificial colorings, and preservatives. So what is a health-conscious mom to do with all that Halloween candy?
The easy way to solve this problem would be to simply not participate in any of these activities that include candy, but that’s just mean! I don’t know about you, but I don’t want my kids to resent me for keeping them from all the fun October festivities, and I also don’t want to rob our family of those fun memories! So here’s a couple ideas for limiting the junk without inhibiting the fun!
Trick or Trade
At our house, we have a very strict no sugar rule. No, this isn’t because we’re sugar Nazis! When our daughter Paislee was a baby, we found out that both her and I were battling Candida, which is basically an overgrowth of yeast in your body. Those of you who have any knowledge of or experience with Candida, know that it’s no little thing! It took us months to finally get healthy again, and we’ve learned that once you have it, you have to really watch what you eat to avoid getting it again. Because of the huge battle we went through, we just don’t allow sugar into our house. It’s not worth the stress and tears we experienced in the past.
So that definitely makes Halloween challenging for us! When recently thinking about how I would allow Paislee to have fun trick or treating this year, without setting her back health-wise, I came up with this “trick or trade” plan!
The basic idea is that you explain to your child before going out why you don’t want them eating the candy. I believe honesty is always the best policy, and that this situation presents a teachable moment for you to explain why candy isn’t healthy. Paislee knows that we don’t eat sugar because “our bodies don’t like it”, so it was easy for me to just explain that candy is full of sugar and isn’t healthy for our bodies.
After your child understands WHY they can’t have the candy, here’s where you get to make it fun! Pick another fun treat or prize you know your child will get excited about, and tell them you will trade this prize with them for all their candy. For Paislee, we are trading her coconut date rolls, stevia sweetened chocolate, and popcorn for all her candy. She couldn’t be more thrilled! When pitching this to your little ones, remember to sell it like it’s your job! We did a little happy dance about all the fun treats she would be getting, and she definitely does not think she’s missing out on anything!
The Candy Fairy
I have my good friend Jennifer to thank for this idea. She is one of my more relaxed friends when it comes to letting your kids have fun treats, which is great because it reminds me that it’s okay to loosen up occasionally. She has decided to let her children join in the candy fun on Halloween, but, like many of us, she doesn’t want it to linger on for weeks. Candy sickened, desperate mothers of the world, I give you the “Candy Fairy”.
In a moment of pure genius, my friend came up with the idea of letting her children indulge on Halloween night, but then prompting them to leave their candy out that night for the Candy Fairy. This magical fairy comes on Halloween night to take your candy, leaving you a fun surprise to play with in it’s place. The beauty of this idea is that it not only gets rid of the candy, but it also just increases the fun factor! The next morning they wake up to something like play dough, a toy car, a doll, etc. It doesn’t need to be expensive, just something they’ll get excited about!
For the Older Children
If your kids are older, chances are that they’re not going to go for either of the suggestions above. I don’t suggest pitching the Candy Fairy to your nine-year-old. You will lose major cool points. However I do suggest using honesty just as I mentioned above. Don’t pass up on the opportunity to explain to them why you don’t want them to eat candy. It will only help them to understand that you’re really not the candy villain.
You might offer a trading system for your older kids that includes something more age appropriate. Pick something of interest to them like art supplies, music, a trip to the dollar store, etc. If you worried about them trying to eat as much as they can in one sitting so that they don’t have to give it up, put a limit on it. Tell them that they get to pick “x” pieces of candy, and the rest gets traded in.
I hope these ideas help you to find that balance in your home between being over-indulgent and unpermissive. Remember to enjoy these moments with your children, and don’t let stress ruin your memories!
What about you? What do you do with the abundance of Halloween candy? I’d love to hear your take on it, and your suggestions!
Photo Credit: Jamal Fanaian